baby food between YUMI or Tiny Organics
January 22, 2021 12:34 pm

Tiny Organics or Yumi: Which baby food subscription is healthiest?

Share this

By purchasing from some (not all) of our links mentioned in this post, we may receive a small commission.

I tend to keep things focused on fitness around here as that’s where my passion lies, however, I’m also a busy mom of two toddlers and feel strongly about the quality of food that they consume.

For all my fellow parents out there, you know that feeding your baby/child quickly becomes one of the most arduous tasks involved in parenthood. There are so many decisions to make and even if you feel like you’ve made the right one, your child will likely have other ideas. It can feel daunting, defeating, and overwhelming all at once.

One thing that has made my life easier over the last couple of years is using a baby food subscription service to get healthy, nutritious meals delivered to my door that my kids will actually eat.

In this article, I’m comparing two very popular kids’ meal delivery services, Yumi and Tiny Organics, giving you an in-depth look at both so that you can choose which one is most aligned with you and your child’s needs.

The Benefits of Subscribing to a Kids’ Meal Delivery Service

Before we get into the specifics of these services, let’s first talk about why you should consider doing so in the first place. Let’s face it, meal delivery services aren’t cheap, so if you’re like me, you want to make sure there’s a darn good reason for adding the extra expense to your family’s bills. So let’s take a look at some of the benefits.

It saves you so much time

Remember when you were pregnant and made an oath that, when the time came, you’d pull out that baby food processor and hand-make all your baby’s food for him/her? Fast forward to a week into it and you realize that it’s much harder than it looks. You have to buy the fruits and vegetables, wash them, cut them, create flavor combinations with them, puree them, and then clean it all up. It’s a lot of work, especially considering much of the mush you created ends up being spit back out onto the highchair tray. Sigh.

Our time is valuable and if we’re spending it going through the cumbersome process of making our own baby food, that means we have less time to spend with our baby. More time with baby means a happier baby and a happier momma.

It can save you money

Do you ever feel outraged when you see the price of fresh, organic produce? It’s darn near criminal what some grocers charge for nature’s bounty. But we suck it up and pay the price because we know the value and nutrients these items provide.

When you use a baby food subscription service like Tiny Organics or Yumi or Little Spoon, they’re making their menu items in bulk each week and passing those savings on to you. No more mulling over every purchasing decision in the grocery store, questioning whether or not your baby really needs to try avocados this week. Let the pros gather all the best fruits and veggies so that your baby can reap the benefits.

Your baby will get a wide exposure to foods

Piggybacking off my last point, by choosing to subscribe to a baby food delivery service, chances are that your little one will have access to more foods and better combinations. I know for me personally, I don’t get super creative with my foods. I like what I like, which makes it difficult to feed my baby things that I may not like myself.

Yumi and Tiny Organics utilize all kinds of fresh, organic foods, creating combinations and recipes that are nutritionally balanced and full of all the things your baby needs to thrive. Left to my own devices, I’m not sure I can pull that off.

Ok, onto what you came here for; the comparison of Tiny Organics vs. Yumi.

The Main Differences and Similarities Between YUMI versus Tiny Organics

Below is a comparison table featuring the most pertinent details about each baby food plan, which will also make clear their similarities and differences.

compare

YUMi

Tiny

Delivery:

Every week

1,2, or 4-week intervals

Meal options:

Pureed Baby Food, Finger Foods (Ages 11 Months +)

Textured finger foods

Choose your menu?:

Yes, each week has a fresh menu available

Yes, rotating menu

Age-appropriate for:

Babies aged 4 months to age 2

Babies and toddlers 8 months +

Delivered fresh or frozen?:

Fresh

Frozen

Organic and Plant-based?:

Yes

Yes

Allergen-free?

Yes

Yes

Shipping Details:

Free to all 48 contiguous United States

Free to all 48 contiguous United States

Compatible with baby-led weaning?:

Yes

Yes

Pricing:

Starting at $3.75 per meal

Starting at $5.49 per meal

Website / Coupon Code

To sum it all up, here are the main differences when choosing between Yumi or Tiny Organics:

  • Yumi delivers fresh food (ready to eat) every week and Tiny Organics delivers frozen food every 1, 2, or 4 weeks.
  • Yumi offers meals that cater to children up to age 2. Tiny Organics offers meals that cater to children up to age 3 or 4.
  • Tiny Organics provides textured baby foods, Yumi offers pureed foods as well as textured foods and bites.
  • Yumi’s meals are appropriate for babies ages 4 months and up (or whenever you choose to start your baby on solids). Tiny Organics is designed to cater to babies 8 months + (possibly younger, depending on each individual baby and their readiness).
  • Yumi offers its Milestone plan which is carefully and scientifically designed to give your baby what they need at every stage of their development. Tiny Organics plan does not delineate between ages or stages.

Tiny Organics Overview

Tiny Organics was founded by two women, Betsy Fore and Sophia Laurell, who realized that there weren’t a lot of options out there for healthy, flavorful, textured foods for babies and toddlers. Their mission is to allow parents the opportunity to create an adventurous eater without all the hassle and guesswork.

With Tiny Organics, parents can introduce their children to their first 100 flavors safely and naturally. All their meals are 100% organic, plant-based, and free of the big 8 allergens. Grounding their meals in science, they aim to help you give your child the most nutritious start to life possible.

The most important thing to know about Tiny Organics is that they do not offer pureed foods, so this is not going to be the brand to turn to if you’re looking to start your young infant on solids. For this plan, you’ll need to wait until your baby is 8 months old or is showing signs of readiness to start solids (something that you should discuss with your pediatrician).

These meals are compatible with baby-led weaning and are created with the perfect texture for little ones. All meals are made fresh and then frozen and delivered to your door. Heating and preparing the meals are simple using the microwave or stovetop to gently warm them to the appropriate temperature.

Yumi Overview

Similar to Tiny Organics, Yumi was founded by two women. This time, they were both moms who were horrified to discover what was inside those jars and pouches of baby food that line the store shelves at your local grocery store.

yumi baby food flavors over tiny organics

YUMI baby food has plenty of flavors to choose from, just like Tiny Organics.

Each week, subscribers have access to a fresh menu of hand-cooked, carefully prepared meals that are nutritious and delicious for babies as young as 4 months old. Yumi’s Milestone plan allows parents to feed their babies the right amount of nutrients at the right time based on their developmental milestones and their changing needs.

All Yumi meals are organic, prepared, and delivered fresh, allergen-free, and free of any added sugars. As mentioned in my detailed review of YUMI, while the meals are delivered to you fresh, you can put them in the freezer for up to 2 months, if needed.

When your baby is beyond the stage of purees and ready for textured foods, Yumi grows with them, offering a selection of textured foods, bites, and puffs that always keep things fun, fresh, and age/stage appropriate.

Final thoughts: Which option is the healthiest? Yumi or Tiny Organics?

Although you came here to answer this question, I’m sorry to say that there is no clear “winner” here. I can absolutely say that both companies offer incredible value and wholesome foods that you can feel great about serving to your little one.

Your decision will need to come down to an analysis of how old your child is right now and whether you want him or her to start with pureed food or if you’re waiting to go down an exclusively baby-led weaning path.

If you have a young baby who’s on the verge of beginning solids for the first time and you want to start with pureed food, go with Yumi. They have an amazing selection of purees that are carefully made for each stage of your baby’s development. 

If you have an older baby, aged 8 months +, and you’d like him/her to begin eating textured foods and you want to introduce them confidently, go with Tiny Organics. That said, you could also go with Yumi and do the same as they also offer textured bites and puffs made for babies aged 8 months plus, but the selection isn’t as extensive.

I also encourage you to consider things like delivery method, fresh or frozen, and delivery frequency when you’re making your decision. Some people love keeping meals in the freezer and not worrying about anything spoiling while others love the idea of serving their baby the freshest possible meals. Take into consideration your wants, needs, and preferences as you choose which one works best for your family.

YUMI Coupon Code: FITMOMMA50 for 50% off and avoid being on their email list

About the author 

Tami Smith

A fitness enthusiast, Tami Smith is an ACE certified fitness trainer, specializing in pre and post-natal fitness. She studied business and earned her bachelor's degree in Business Economics. Tami is a mom of two and women's health advocate. Her passion is to help people live a fit, healthy life!

You may also like

Leave a Reply

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Join the Fit Home, Healthy Life Facebook Group