Caraway Bakeware Set Review: Worth It? A Nutritionist Examines

By Tami Smith

FHM is reader supported - by purchasing through our links, we may earn a small commission.

rating caraway bakeware set

Fit Healthy Momma Rating: 9.5/10

Caraway Bakeware is well-designed kitchenware that’s built to last. With the full set, you have everything you need to bake healthy, delicious meals without any hassle or extensive cleanup. Plus, they’re beautiful, clean, and easy to store.

Take a peek inside your kitchen cupboard where you store your bakeware; what do you see? A pile of old, random pieces that have seen better days?

That’s been the story of my cupboards for years. Old, dingy, worn bakeware that’s tucked, turned and tossed in there any which way. It wasn’t pretty, to say the least.

After being gifted the Caraway Cookware set for Christmas and loving how simple, clean, and functional it was, I was thrilled to get my hands on Caraway’s Bakeware set so that I could give my bakeware section the same facelift as my cookware. 

In this article, I’m reviewing the Caraway Bakeware set, giving you all the details you need to decide if this set is worth it for you.

Quick Summary of Caraway Bakeware Review

Product:

Options:

11 piece set or 5 piece set

What's included:

2x Storage, Baking Sheet, Muffin Pan, Rectangle Pan, Cooling Rack, Square Pan, Loaf Pan, Circle Pans

Website:

Best for:

Making healthier baking a piece of cake without chemicals.

Price:

5 piece set: $295, 11 piece set: $545

Discounts / Coupons:

They often run sales, so be sure to check that out here.

Avg. User Rating:

4.9/5 (Over 1,500 reviews)

FHM Rating:

9.5/10 ⭐

summary information caraway bakeware set

Introducing The Caraway Bakeware Set

bakeware set by caraway

The complete Caraway Bakeware set comes with 11 pieces of ceramic-coated bakeware, perfect for outfitting any kitchen. All pieces feature a toxin-free surface, allowing you to enjoy your baked goods without any of the “bads” that are common with traditional bakeware.

The Caraway Bakeware set comes in five different color options, allowing you to customize the look of your pieces to suit your kitchen style and ambiance. Even better, the set comes equipped with convenient storage organizers to keep your kitchen looking fresh and tidy.

What Makes Caraway Unique?

Caraway is unique in that they are on a mission to do one thing: craft well-designed home goods that raise the standards of what you cook with. In other words, the Caraway team is dedicated to making products that help make your life healthier and easier.

Furthermore, Caraway is unique in that they offer full, curated cooking and baking sets that add an aesthetic touch to any kitchen. With five beautiful different colors to choose from, the hardest part will be deciding which color to go with.

Lastly, Caraway takes their attention to detail and commitment to making your life simpler and easier by offering storage racks for their cooking and bakeware. No more messy, cluttered cupboards or countertops, every piece in Caraway’s collections have a tidy home.

Pros

  • Crafted with high-quality materials
  • Non-stick
  • Non-toxic
  • Simple to clean
  • Even heat distribution
  • Everything you need in one beautiful set
  • 5 color options to choose from
  • Aluminized Steel Body + Stainless Steel Handles
  • Storage included
  • Option to choose a half set if you don’t need all 11 pieces

Cons

  • Cannot be run through the dishwasher (can disrupt the integrity of the materials)
  • Not as cost-effective as other bakeware options (but you get what you pay for)

What’s Included?

the caraway bakeware set

Caraway’s full bakeware set includes 11 essential baking pieces that will help make sure your kitchen is fully functional when it comes to your baking needs. Whether you frequently bake cupcakes and cakes or you’re a casserole queen, you’ll find the quality, non-stick bakeware you need to craft healthy, delicious meals and treats.

Here’s what’s included with the Caraway Bakeware full set:

  • 18 x 13” Baking Sheet
  • 10 x 15” Baking Sheet
  • 12 Cup Muffin Pan
  • 9 x 13” Rectangle Pan
  • 8 x 13” Cooling Rack
  • 9” Square Pan
  • 1lb Loaf Pan
  • 9” Circle Pans x2
  • Storage Rack x2

Weight and Dimensions

If you’re a serious baker, you know that having the right-sized dishes is imperative for recipe creation. Below is a quick table showing the dimensions of each piece in the bakeware collection.

Product Width (in) Length (in) Weight (lbs)
Medium Baking Sheet 10 15 2
Large Baking Sheet 13 18 4
Cooling Rack 13 18 2
Rectangle Pan 9 13 3
Muffin Pan 10 15 2
Square Pan 9 9 1
Loaf Pan 5 9 1
Round Cake Pan 9 9 1

Why Choose Caraway Bakeware?

If you’re like me, you’ve had several sets of bakeware in your kitchen. You use the stuff for a year or two, they get grubby, stained, and terrible-looking, and you toss them only to replace them with yet another of the same.

Deciding to break the cycle of purchasing crappy bakeware is one of the best decisions you’ll ever make. Although the cost is more upfront, you can count on Caraway lasting you for years, thereby making it the cheaper, more efficient option in the long run.

Other reasons to choose Caraway over the competition include:

  • Non-toxic - the materials used in the non-stick coating are safe for your family and the environment.
  • Non-stick - your baked goods will release easily from the pans, eliminating the need for excessive amounts of foil and cooking oils/sprays.
  • Easy to clean - a quick, gentle wash is all your Caraware Bakeware needs to wash away residue and maintain its brilliance.
  • Even heat distribution - cooking with Caraway means that you’re getting evenly cooked or baked foods, there are no hot spots.
  • Included storage - with organizers included, you can easily and safely store your bakeware when not in use and keep your kitchen looking tidy. 
  • Five colors to choose from - instead of going with the standard black or gray that’s common among other bakeware sets, Caraway offers five gorgeous color options to choose from.

Alternatives

Obviously, not everyone has the same tastes, needs, and preferences, which is why we always like to provide you with an alternative or two to see if there’s something else out there that might be a better fit for your unique needs.

If you’d prefer a porcelain bakeware set, Made-In Cookware offers a set that fits the bill. These have a ton of 5-star reviews, but each set only comes with 3 pieces, so you’d have to find your other necessities elsewhere. 

If affordability is at the top of your list, Rachel Ray has a great bakeware set that’s very affordable and offers pretty decent quality. This 10-piece set has a great selection of common bakeware essentials that will help equip your kitchen with what you need to handle all your baking needs. The style is basic and the quality is sub-par compared to higher-end options like Caraway, however, those on a budget will appreciate the lower price tag.

Honest Caraway Reviews and Average Rating

The average rating from verified customers that purchased the Caraway Bakeware Set is 4.9/5 stars with over 1,500 reviews. You'll find that the majority of people love the quality of the set and that it really helps those who love to bake.

I always encourage my readers to read more reviews of a product before purchasing so you do your due diligence. Below, I put together a couple images of the average rating and reviews of Caraway Bakeware set from verified buyers.

caraway bakeware average rating and customer review
caraway bakeware customer review "great quality"

Final Thoughts: Is Caraway Bakeware Worth it?

Caraway Bakeware is 100% worth it if you’re looking for a high-quality set of bakeware that’s not only aesthetically pleasing, but functional, healthy, and built to last for years without losing its integrity.

As someone who has cycled through dozens of pieces of bakeware over the years due to it losing its non-stick coating, getting tarnished, or stained, I can attest to the fact that you truly do get what you pay for. So while Caraway isn’t the cheapest option on the market, you can rest assured that you’re getting higher-quality pieces that you can rely on and enjoy for years to come.

Personally, I love how easy it is to clean Caraway products and how I hardly use any cooking oils or sprays with their pieces, saving me excess calories and helping to make my meals and snacks healthier. I also enjoy that the set comes with its own storage organizers. Previously, my bakeware cupboard was haphazardly stacked together, Caraway makes things so much easier and tidier.

About the author 

Tami Smith

Tami Smith is a certified Nutritionist and an ACE certified fitness trainer, specializing in pre and post-natal fitness. She studied business and earned her bachelor's degree in Business Economics. Tami is a mom of two and women's health advocate. Her passion is to help people live a fit, healthy life through proper nutrition and exercise!

You may also like

Leave a Reply

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Join the Fit Home, Healthy Life Facebook Group